HIRING GUIDE · INTERVIEWS

Interview candidates with a clear plan.

A good conversation can leave you feeling confident without telling you whether someone can do the job. Use a scorecard, consistent questions, and examples of their work to make the decision.

Before interviewing, decide what the person needs to do and what evidence would show they can do it. Ask consistent questions, explore specific examples and record what you learn. Compare candidates against the job, including their motivation, working preferences and responsibility for outcomes.

Start with what the job needs

Write down what you need this person to accomplish, the skills they need on arrival and what you can teach. Use that list to prepare questions about the experience behind the resume. Explain the actual work so the candidate can decide whether it suits them too.

A one-page scorecard can be enough: list the job requirements, the questions you will ask and space for examples from each answer. Agree on what a strong answer would show before you meet the candidates.

What did the candidate actually demonstrate?

It is easy to leave an interview thinking, “I liked them.” That matters for a working relationship, but it leaves questions unanswered. What have they done that is relevant? How did they approach the difficult parts? What would they need to learn here?

Notice your impressions, then ask what evidence supports them. A useful debrief separates what the candidate demonstrated from what you assumed.

Four ways to check whether someone can do the work

Use the questions, exercises and reference checks that help answer what you still need to know about this role.

1. The scorecard

Write down a few outcomes that would make someone successful in the role. Identify the skills needed, decide what evidence to look for, and define your rating criteria. A one-page scorecard can keep the interview team focused without creating a pile of paperwork.

Look through and print an example interview scorecard to see how the questions, criteria, and notes fit together. No account is needed to view the example. Generating scorecards for your own roles in MS Rosie, our hiring software, is included in the paid plan.

Use the interview worksheet in the field guide to prepare questions and record the evidence before comparing candidates.

2. The structured interview

Use consistent core questions and criteria across candidates, while following up on what each person says. There is no silver-bullet interview question. The job, industry, and gaps in your understanding should guide the conversation. OPM’s structured-interview guidance explains the value of consistent questions and evaluation.

To answer “Can they do this work?”, start with a specific example from the candidate’s past, identify the skill they used, and ask them to apply it to a concrete part of your job. Then ask what would need to change. You are listening for how they connect their experience to the work you actually need done.

We call this the Behavioral Bridge: connecting a real past example to the work in your role.

Jay’s view, from nearly twenty-eight years in recruiting: “In my experience, the Behavioral Bridge is harder to fake because candidates have to connect a specific past experience to the actual work in front of them.”

Ask three other questions separately: “Do they want this work?” explores motivation, “Will this working environment suit them?” explores the day-to-day demands and team, and “How do they take responsibility when things go wrong?” explores accountability. For the last question, ask what they could influence, what they did and what happened. Evidence of skill alone does not answer these questions.

3. A short example of the work

Use a short, relevant exercise when seeing the work would help. A sales candidate could discuss a fictional account plan; an estimator could work through an anonymized example. Explain the task and assess everyone against the same criteria. Keep the exercise proportionate, and explore the candidate’s reasoning as well as the result.

4. References who have seen them work

Ask references about the work you need the person to do. “How did Pat handle a missed deadline?” is more useful than a request for general praise. Explore what happened, what support was needed, and what the reference directly observed. Treat limited or unavailable references as a gap to understand, rather than proof of a problem.

What personality tests are good for

Be clear about what an assessment measures and whether it is appropriate for your purpose. Do not treat a personality label as a complete picture of someone or a substitute for job-related evidence. If you plan to use a test in selection, get qualified guidance on its use and interpretation.

Example: interviewing someone from a different industry

Illustrative example: a small plumbing company is hiring a dispatcher. A candidate has managed retail schedules but has not dispatched service technicians. The owner asks how that experience would transfer to dispatching:

  1. Start with a specific experience. “Tell me about a time someone called out and you had to change the day’s schedule. What did you do, and what happened?”
  2. Identify the skill. “How did you decide which work needed coverage first and who could cover it?” Follow the details to understand how they set priorities and communicate changes.
  3. Apply it to this job. “Here, a technician might call out when we already have a full day of booked visits and an urgent leak comes in. How would you use that approach to adjust our schedule?”
  4. Ask what must change. “What would you need to do differently when you also have to account for travel time and which technician can handle each job? What would you need to learn from us?”

Compare the answers with the dispatcher’s actual responsibilities. The candidate may show useful experience, a gap that needs training, or an unanswered question for a work sample. This is an example of an interview conversation, not a reported client result.

Common questions about interviewing candidates

Why do I keep making bad hires even when interviews go well?

A comfortable conversation does not tell you everything about how someone will do the work. Start by defining what the job needs, then look for specific examples, relevant work, and references that help you check the evidence. Also review what happens after the hire: unclear expectations, missing training, or a mismatch between the job described and the job delivered can undermine a good decision.

What's the difference between a structured interview and a regular one?

A structured interview gives every candidate for the same role a consistent set of core questions and uses agreed criteria to evaluate the answers. It can still be a real conversation. Ask follow-up questions, make room for the candidate’s questions, and listen carefully. The structure helps you cover what matters and compare evidence afterward; it should not turn the meeting into an interrogation.

How do I create an interview scorecard for a small business?

Start with the outcomes the person needs to deliver and the skills needed to get there. For each one, write down a question or short exercise, what a strong answer would demonstrate, and space for evidence. For example, a customer-service role might include resolving a complaint: listen for how the candidate understood the problem, chose an action, and checked the result. Define what your rating scale means before interviewing. Record examples before making the overall decision.

How do I assess for skills I don't have myself?

Bring in someone who understands the work, such as a trusted colleague, adviser, or specialist. Agree on a short, relevant exercise and how it will be assessed. Ask the candidate to explain their approach in plain language, including assumptions and trade-offs. Use references to explore specific parts of their experience. You do not need to pretend to be the technical expert to run a thoughtful process.

What interview questions should I ask candidates?

Choose questions around the work you need done. To explore whether someone can do the job, ask: “Tell me about a specific time you handled something like this. What did you do, and what happened?” Identify the skill behind the example, then describe a concrete task in your role and ask, “How would you apply that skill here? What would need to change?” Follow their reasoning and ask what they would need to learn. Keep it conversational and use the same job criteria across candidates. Ask separately about motivation, the working environment, and responsibility for outcomes. A capable answer does not cover all three.

Are personality tests worth using for SMB hiring?

A personality label should not replace evidence about the work. If you use an assessment, understand what it measures, whether it is appropriate for the role, and how the results should be interpreted. Get qualified advice before making it part of a hiring decision. The EEOC explains the responsibilities that come with employment testing. For many small businesses, a useful starting point is clearer job criteria, good conversations, and relevant work examples.

What is a work sample and how do I create one?

A work sample is a short exercise based on something the person would do in the job. A sales candidate might discuss a fictional prospect. An accounting candidate might review a small fictional spreadsheet. Choose a task that tests a skill needed on entry, explain the instructions and time commitment, and decide how you will evaluate it before using it. Keep the task proportionate and use fictional or anonymized material rather than asking candidates to produce unpaid client work.

How many interviews should a small business run per candidate?

Use the fewest conversations that let both sides make an informed decision. Give each stage a purpose. If two managers need to meet the candidate, consider a joint interview or back-to-back meetings instead of separate trips. Tell candidates what to expect at the start. Add another stage only when you can name the unanswered question it will resolve.

How do I assess accountability in a job interview?

Ask about a situation that did not go to plan. Explore what the candidate could influence, what was outside their control, what they did next, and what they learned. Look for specific actions and a realistic account of the circumstances. Accountability matters, but it is not a single test that predicts whether a hire will work out. Consider it alongside capability, motivation, and the working environment.

Previous: Keep candidates engaged. Next: Make offers.

Use the example to build your own scorecard. If you need help preparing interviews or evaluating candidates, talk with us about recruiting support for your business.