THE COMPARISON

Eleven ways to get hiring done.

Compare the work covered, the costs, and the help your team needs.

Start with who will do the work. Will someone on your team run the search, will you hire a recruiter, or will you bring in outside help? Then compare the actual responsibilities, capacity and total cost. The eleven options below are a checklist for that conversation, not a ranking of providers.

Three starting points

The main difference is who takes on the daily recruiting work. Here is our starting point for deciding which model to investigate. Specific services and responsibilities still need to be agreed.

CompareDIY with softwareRecruiting serviceInternal recruiter
Who does the daily workAn owner, manager or HR team runs hiring. Software helps organize applicants and automate selected tasks.An outside recruiter handles agreed work, such as finding and screening candidates or coordinating the search.Your employee finds, screens and interviews candidates as part of their assigned recruiting role.
Worth considering whenYou have someone with the time and experience to run the search, and need tools or a clearer process.You need recruiting capacity or experience your team cannot supply, for a particular search or ongoing hiring.You expect enough continuing recruiting work to support a permanent role and can manage that employee.
What you still ownThe whole process: deciding where to look, reviewing candidates, following up, interviewing and making the offer.Job requirements, interview feedback, pay and the hiring decision. Agree who handles every remaining step.Hiring priorities, budget, management of the recruiter and the decisions assigned to each hiring manager.
How costs are structuredYour team's time, plus any advertising and software costs. Some job boards offer both free and paid postings.A provider fee under the agreed terms. Examples include a placement fee or a monthly plan. Our plans charge monthly.Employee pay and related employment costs, plus recruiting tools and advertising. Budget for the role between searches too.

On a small screen, scroll sideways to compare the three approaches →

Examples behind this overview: Indeed's free and paid posting options, BLS descriptions of recruiter duties, and Robert Half's recruiting process and placement-fee reporting. These illustrate the models, rather than terms promised by every provider.

Start with the decision in front of you

Doing it yourself? Name the person who will review applicants, contact candidates and keep interviews moving. Put that time on the calendar before buying another tool.

Considering an agency? Define the role and ask what happens between the first introduction and the start date. Confirm the fee, payment trigger and any replacement terms in writing.

Considering an internal recruiter or ongoing outside help? List the roles you expect to open, the work between searches and who will manage priorities. Compare an employee, a contract recruiter, a fractional recruiter and recruitment process outsourcing (RPO) against that same list.

The comparison checklist

Each cell is a question to settle with your team or a prospective provider. Get written answers for your actual roles. A service label alone does not tell you the price, the recruiter's experience or how much work stays with you. The fractional column includes questions to ask us.

What to clarify
before choosing
Ad-Hoc
DIY Hiring
Offshore
Sourcing
Virtual
Assistant
AI
Recruiting
FT Internal
Recruiter
Fractional
Recruiter
Agency
Contingent
Agency
Staffing
Contract
Recruiter
RPO Agency
Retained
Work to define Who owns the search from posting to start date? Candidate research, outreach or screening too? Scheduling and admin, or candidate screening too? Which tasks does the tool perform, and who reviews them? Which roles and recruiting tasks belong to this hire? Which steps and open roles are included in our plan? Candidate introductions or management of the whole search? Temporary coverage, temp-to-hire or direct hire? A specific project, open roles or ongoing recruiting? Which parts of your recruiting process would transfer? What research, assessment and search milestones are included?
Costs to confirm Advertising, tools and hours taken from other work? Hourly, project or monthly fees? Are tools extra? Hours, minimum commitment and recruiting tool costs? Seats, usage limits, setup and integration charges? Salary, benefits, tools and recruiting support? Monthly price, included capacity and any extra costs? Fee calculation, payment trigger and replacement terms? Hourly bill rate, overtime and conversion fees? Hourly or fixed fee? What happens if the project extends? Setup fees, minimum spend and charges as volume changes? Payment milestones and terms if the search changes?
Capacity to check Who has time each week to keep candidates moving? How many prospects, and how is relevance checked? How many hours and what recruiting experience? What input, monitoring and corrections will your team supply? Is there enough work for the role between searches? How many roles can run at once, and who sets priorities? Who works your role, and how often will you hear from them? Can the firm cover your shifts, location and skill requirements? How many hours, for how long, and with what backup? How does staffing change when your hiring volume changes? Who leads the search, and what comparable roles have they handled?
Handoffs to settle Who screens, schedules, gives feedback and makes the offer? Who takes a prospect from first reply through interview? Who makes screening decisions and answers candidate questions? When does a person take over from the tool? What decisions stay with the hiring manager? What do we handle, and what feedback do we need from you? Who manages your own applicants alongside agency candidates? Who handles payroll, onboarding and day-to-day supervision? Who owns candidate records and unfinished work at contract end? Who owns systems, reporting and candidate communication? Who checks references, discusses the offer and follows up?
Evidence to request What has your last search shown about the biggest bottleneck? Can you review a sample list against your actual requirements? Can they demonstrate the tasks you need completed? Can you try it on a real workflow and inspect the output? Can the candidate explain results from comparable hiring work? Can we show how the proposed plan handles your current hiring problem? What recent searches show experience with this type of role? What shows they can supply the people and coverage you need? What examples show they can deliver within your timeframe? What reporting and transition plan will you receive? What search plan and progress reports will you receive?

Scroll the chart sideways to see all eleven options →

See how fractional works or start a conversation.

Compare the same work

Write down one current role and the steps you need help with. Ask each provider to price that work, name the person responsible and explain what your team still needs to do. Include the cost of tools and your own time. Compare the total for the same expected hiring workload.

Look past the start date

Ask who stays in touch after the offer, who helps if the new hire struggles and what happens if they leave. A replacement promise and support for keeping a hire are different things. Get the details of each.

If you are considering ongoing recruiting help, read what fractional recruiting is and what it costs, then compare our plans. Bring the same checklist to us.

"What would this look like for my business?"

Start a Conversation